Rating: 6 Okay, I'm confused. The Gold NMM on the bolter (and chest) and the battle damage both look great! The head, shoulders and backpack look like a 4.0 mini. Either it's the photograph, like Sanguinius said, or you should really try to bring it all up to the same level, like your great Elf.
Rating: 8 This is way more than tabletop mate It has great shading and detailing only the photo is bad but I recognize a good painting. Check out mine minis. Cheers!