Rating: 8 I really like this, your color choice and dark tones really make him feel like hes been through alot. However I would have added some very small bright highlights to the edges of your blackest paint chips to give them some depth. Cheers!
Rating: 9 Nice battlesuit! The weathering and conversion are pretty good. The scratches and impacts could use a small higlight on the bottom edge to emphasize the 3D aspect of them. Still excellent though!