Search Results - CoolMiniOrNot Forums

Search:

Type: Posts; User: Codfather

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    2
    Views
    433

    It is most likely an error of omission if you...

    It is most likely an error of omission if you compare it to the likes of Hold the Line (or at the very least, inconsistent rule writing, either way, shitty QC). But It's pretty clear that like hold...
  2. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,531

    https://asoiaf-stats.com/tournaments Find the...

    https://asoiaf-stats.com/tournaments

    Find the NRG tournament then go to player standing
  3. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,531

    https://asoiaf-stats.com/tournaments Find the...

    https://asoiaf-stats.com/tournaments

    Find the NRG tournament then go to player standing
  4. Replies
    6
    Views
    745

    Units aren't generally an issue (maybe 3 units of...

    Units aren't generally an issue (maybe 3 units of stark outriders) but having a field allowance for attachments could be good. Might limit 6 skinchangers lists and allows for some strong attachments...
  5. Replies
    6
    Views
    603

    I don't think you'd be able to spend a token for...

    I don't think you'd be able to spend a token for the "after the attack" trigger if the attack destroyed the unit, since destroyed (and subsequent removal of the unit) occurs before "after the attack"...
  6. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,531

    That's his point

    That's his point
  7. Replies
    3
    Views
    412

    So basically the question boils down to: Do...

    So basically the question boils down to:

    Do you have a "start of friendly turn" trigger window when you have no more combat or ncu activations left?


    I would very much like to know as well
  8. Replies
    5
    Views
    568

    Ya, its basically a conditional extra activation,...

    Ya, its basically a conditional extra activation, which can potentially offset a disadvantage if you are only playing 6-7 activations
  9. Replies
    2
    Views
    371

    Those two have trigger conflicts, however, last...

    Those two have trigger conflicts, however, last stand and counter charge do not, so thats a sweet combo. Or if you wanna get really crazy:

    Renly's unit gets killed and killed
    Last stand for...
  10. Bonelords chosen are much better with commander...

    Bonelords chosen are much better with commander Styr or commander Weeper
  11. There is currently 7 factions available to play...

    There is currently 7 factions available to play but Shinnal has talked about in a recentish podcast that back in the kickstarter days (2017?) they had 9 factions planned at that time. By now, they...
  12. Replies
    2
    Views
    654

    If your opponent uses their Varys to grab a zone...

    If your opponent uses their Varys to grab a zone before you've gone with your Walder, you can use your Varys to turn off the enemy Varys for the round, which would mean your Walder can activate...
  13. Ya I'd say that 9 activations is fine, probably...

    Ya I'd say that 9 activations is fine, probably the number you should be aiming for as freefolk. Even 8 is OK if you are going for a newly viable "elite" build (Bonelords Chosen, Giants, etc)
  14. Replies
    1
    Views
    325

    When a unit would swing with its green attack...

    When a unit would swing with its green attack value it is considered to have full ranks. Therefore yes, 0-3 wounds the unit is still at full ranks.
  15. Replies
    9
    Views
    698

    Cut them down triggers twice its true, but what...

    Cut them down triggers twice its true, but what serbaelish is saying is its technically not "stacking" its just being triggered two times on different units.

    It's a semantic arguement, but...
  16. Replies
    10
    Views
    1,414

    Endless hordes can be game winning, but I would...

    Endless hordes can be game winning, but I would agree that unless you can use it on the turn coming up, you probably want to pitch it. Don't hold onto it if you can't use it quickly.
  17. Replies
    9
    Views
    698

    In your case it would be d3+5 wounds!! Cut them...

    In your case it would be d3+5 wounds!! Cut them down OP!
  18. Replies
    4
    Views
    456

    I guess it's possible its an oversight, but...

    I guess it's possible its an oversight, but nothing in the rules seem to prevent it at all.
  19. Trick to dealing with giants is similar to...

    Trick to dealing with giants is similar to dealing with Poor fellows. You need to be able to double tap it without it activating in between. Fair amount of the time, 2 hits will kill either unit
  20. Replies
    18
    Views
    2,414

    So, mighty enhancement on a scorpion for...

    So, mighty enhancement on a scorpion for re-rolls. Its sounding like you get a choice if you want to use crit blow, or the scorpions own rule? You don't HAVE to use crit blow?
  21. Replies
    6
    Views
    510

    As Alliser is pointing out, even if you...

    As Alliser is pointing out, even if you completely cover a corpse pile, if you fail a panic check you still lsot control of the objective. Yes that objective may be placed completely under your base,...
  22. The 7pts means if you want any ncus in your list...

    The 7pts means if you want any ncus in your list you can max take 4 giants, and if you do take 4 giants, there's also no way to get 3 ncus. It's possible it may be as you said, maybe I'll give it a...
  23. 1. The 1.5 change to losing abilities is...

    1. The 1.5 change to losing abilities is strictly for if the effect says removes abilities from the unit. If it specifically says attack abilities or attachment abilities, it only removes those. ...
  24. Replies
    3
    Views
    553

    The trigger window would have passed for you to...

    The trigger window would have passed for you to do it in that order, however, I believe you're able to play it and then pull it back.

    The trigger windows are the same, so you'd effectively be...
  25. Replies
    12
    Views
    1,434

    At LVO the top table had 1 Walder I believe...

    At LVO the top table had 1 Walder I believe across the 4 lists, though winner did use Walder.

    At Bretts tournament there were only 2 Walders, 1 of which the list never got used all day, and there...
  26. Replies
    12
    Views
    1,434

    I'm not sure if tournament data yet supports...

    I'm not sure if tournament data yet supports this. I only have 2 examples so perhaps they were outliers, but Brett Lanpher ran a 24 person tournament which only had 2-3 Freys across all lists and 0...
  27. If you read shyra ability, It comes into play...

    If you read shyra ability, It comes into play when she CLAIMS a zone which happens after she activates. New Varys triggers when an NCU activates, so he can blank her before she claims a zone and...
  28. Actually, nothing. You are correct, Varys can use...

    Actually, nothing. You are correct, Varys can use his ability when Mel activates.

    However, the trigger for Mel's ability also occurrs when she activates, so the trigger for her ability and varys...
  29. For reference 78075

    For reference
    78075
  30. Replies
    12
    Views
    1,434

    It's what Warmachine used to follow, tho that...

    It's what Warmachine used to follow, tho that system got rid of it. It does actually create an interesting dilemma in list creation since you have to allocate where strong named characters will be...
  31. As far as I'm aware, start of round effects would...

    As far as I'm aware, start of round effects would resolve in turn order. So if player A is going first that round, Player A resolves their cruel methods first.
  32. Oddly enough, even tho the aesthetic is that of a...

    Oddly enough, even tho the aesthetic is that of a massed battle game, ASOIAF plays very much like a skirmish game with movement restrictions. It's alternating activation where each unit is basically...
  33. As baelish says, it doesn't say to shuffle your...

    As baelish says, it doesn't say to shuffle your deck, and there are many similar effects that do (and ones that were printed before nights watch released, like Sansa).

    I disagree with his...
  34. Replies
    2
    Views
    293

    You are correct. It's particularly good with...

    You are correct. It's particularly good with Stark sworn swords and Syrio since his precision adding isn't an order, nor does it have a downside, outside of the normal stark fury tax (though it...
  35. Replies
    45
    Views
    7,090

    Ya speed 3 probably wont happen, but if they are...

    Ya speed 3 probably wont happen, but if they are indeed 2+ arm, i'd be very surprised if they were faster than speed 4. Unless maybe their moral is really bad, but that seems unlikely with Baratheons
  36. Replies
    45
    Views
    7,090

    I suspect if anything gets a 2+ save in this...

    I suspect if anything gets a 2+ save in this game, it will be super slow, like speed 3 (which if cav is still faster than normal infantry)
  37. I think as Alliser pointed out, I think you're...

    I think as Alliser pointed out, I think you're confusing what ferocious assault does (give the charged unit a panic token). This rule has increased Flayed men's damage significantly on the charge
  38. Replies
    10
    Views
    849

    Asmodee at least does have a robust replacement...

    Asmodee at least does have a robust replacement portal, they will easily send you replacement models for anything broken for free. Sucks ya gotta use broken stuff in the mean time tho
  39. Thread: Sentinels

    by Codfather
    Replies
    7
    Views
    1,084

    They are a good unit for Renly to sit in since he...

    They are a good unit for Renly to sit in since he helps their moral and their offense (which is their main role). Decent bunker for Commander Daario as well as he helps their save and moral as well.
  40. Replies
    10
    Views
    849

    Yep sounds about right. Great game, shit...

    Yep sounds about right.

    Great game, shit distribution
  41. Just like you can't use the hold the line order...

    Just like you can't use the hold the line order with cruel method, cant use executions fury either.

    Interestingly enough though, both those CAN be used on the charge if you use Robs tactical...
  42. Replies
    6
    Views
    559

    He also doesn't straight out counter cards like...

    He also doesn't straight out counter cards like endless hordes, sudden charge, orders to destroy etc anymore
  43. Replies
    63
    Views
    1,827

    More than 100 people play this game

    More than 100 people play this game
  44. Replies
    8
    Views
    830

    As would I, his word is official in the rules...

    As would I, his word is official in the rules forums. But not everyone reads the rules forums, and he seemed to be under the assumption that it was already in the FAQ, maybe it accidently slipped...
  45. In some games the dice will be with the...

    In some games the dice will be with the lannisters and the kingsgiard won't get killed in 1-3 turns by the stone thrower, but man that is some variance I am not willing to take unless my paired list...
  46. Replies
    63
    Views
    1,827

    OK, I think understand where you are getting...

    OK, I think understand where you are getting confused.

    In this game, any action, ability, card, order dice roll etc creates a response window before it is finalized. Within that response window...
  47. Replies
    63
    Views
    1,827

    I'm starting to think this guy is just taking the...

    I'm starting to think this guy is just taking the piss
  48. Replies
    63
    Views
    1,827

    Why do you think Prey on fear is triggered before...

    Why do you think Prey on fear is triggered before the captain gives the at any cost order?
  49. Thankfully with the recent changes, Joffrey and...

    Thankfully with the recent changes, Joffrey and the Kingsguard are a very solid lannister option now. Though, still garbage into the stonethrower
  50. Whoa, that would be far to strong for 3pts. ...

    Whoa, that would be far to strong for 3pts. Joffrey ncu does that for the crown, but thats all he does, and he's 4pts, and he panics one of your units.

    I don't think lady Val is an auto include...
  51. Replies
    8
    Views
    830

    It seems Northern Ferocity has been FAQ'd, but...

    It seems Northern Ferocity has been FAQ'd, but group assault has not
  52. Replies
    9
    Views
    699

    The key term here is "generate hits". Although I...

    The key term here is "generate hits". Although I don't think it is defined in the rule book, it has been talked about at length by Shinnal on podcasts, and maybe even elsewhere in this forum, I'm...
  53. Starks: Swords/Horse Lannister: Crown/Wealth...

    Starks: Swords/Horse
    Lannister: Crown/Wealth
    Neutral: Wealth/Letters
    Nights Watch: Depends on what vows they have on the board, their strongest ones however are probably the Wealth, Letters and...
  54. Free Folk really open up when you get the Heroes...

    Free Folk really open up when you get the Heroes box and having 4 units of raiders is a must I'd say as it forms a solid core for every list to be built around. Units like Cave Dwellers and Thenns...
  55. Basically, for things like pyromancers or great...

    Basically, for things like pyromancers or great axes, all hits (unless they are blocked by things like Wealth of the Rock) become unblocked hits. Then all unblocked hits become wounds. This...
  56. Replies
    10
    Views
    1,446

    I suspect when he said wargame he meant more of...

    I suspect when he said wargame he meant more of the mass army wargames, like Warmachine, 40k, AOS, kings of war etc.

    I'm curious to hear what you feel are the glaring balance issues that the...
  57. Replies
    10
    Views
    1,446

    It could be your local stores or regional...

    It could be your local stores or regional suppliers. Here in Canada in the same city one store sells unit boxes for $30CAD, the other sells them for $40CAD
  58. Replies
    63
    Views
    1,827

    I'm not sure where the confusion is occurring...

    I'm not sure where the confusion is occurring here. This is a rough sequence of events:

    Unit (with At Any Cost order available) is forced to take a panic check
    Unit MUST take that panic check...
  59. Whoa, I had not seen the back of the skinchanger...

    Whoa, I had not seen the back of the skinchanger card...
  60. Only 1 attachment per unit, except in rare cases...

    Only 1 attachment per unit, except in rare cases like rickon and osha
  61. Replies
    8
    Views
    460

    There is a fair amount of counter play against...

    There is a fair amount of counter play against Frey and when you can shut him down its pretty sad spending 5pts on him.

    -With the exception of FF, everyone has the option of taking Varys, which...
  62. Replies
    9
    Views
    724

    Huh, well there goes my theory

    Huh, well there goes my theory
  63. Replies
    2
    Views
    318

    Vanguard Commander & Feinting Maneuver

    If a Harma player triggers the Maneuver zone and plays Feinting Maneuver, can Harma use her Vanguard commander ability to take that take Feinting Maneuver card back, since active player controls...
  64. Thanks for posting this. As you've pointed out...

    Thanks for posting this. As you've pointed out the crux of the issue stems from whether or not the 2 side trays are actually touching the charger on the corner tangent or not. If they are, RAW they...
  65. Replies
    9
    Views
    724

    Ah I see. So if something removes a units...

    Ah I see. So if something removes a units abilities it removes both the units ability and what the attachment grants. However if something specifies attachment, it only turns off that attachment.
    ...
  66. Replies
    9
    Views
    724

    The change is not necessary anymore. The core...

    The change is not necessary anymore. The core rules changed so that anything that takes away either a units or an attachments ability, now takes away both.
  67. Replies
    15
    Views
    2,176

    If the previous errata's are any indication, the...

    If the previous errata's are any indication, the cards will be properly sized in the PDF. If you really want better quality new cards, take the pdfs to a print shop and have them printed for you
  68. I think FF in general got a decent buff with the...

    I think FF in general got a decent buff with the new panic changes
  69. Replies
    6
    Views
    460

    The way I like to think about it is basically...

    The way I like to think about it is basically that same named abilities don't stack on a single unit, but that doesn't mean same named abilities can't trigger off the same event. For example, 'Cut...
  70. Damn, that's too bad

    Damn, that's too bad
  71. That's a good point. Guess it matter WHERE he...

    That's a good point. Guess it matter WHERE he said the text in question is just a reminder was said. I don't recall myself
  72. I agree, but that's the reasoning occurring in...

    I agree, but that's the reasoning occurring in this thread
  73. If I understand the point, as a Stark Player...

    If I understand the point, as a Stark Player using Rickon, it is ALWAYS in the Stark Players best interest to orient a Rickon unit from left to right (facing forward) as Osha -> Rickon -> rest of...
  74. Replies
    12
    Views
    723

    Alrighty, I finally understand! There is no...

    Alrighty, I finally understand! There is no "after defense dice are rolled" trigger window after a vulnerable reroll!

    But Goddamn that is unintuitive!
  75. Replies
    12
    Views
    723

    Hmmm, maybe I'm starting to get it. Is the only...

    Hmmm, maybe I'm starting to get it. Is the only trigger window for "after defense dice are rolled" before a potential vulnerable reroll?
  76. Replies
    12
    Views
    723

    I still don't understand why that is though. ...

    I still don't understand why that is though.

    On pg 24 of the rule book under conditions it basically says condition tokens are spent after dice are rolled which I suppose explains why a weakened...
  77. Replies
    12
    Views
    723

    Of course you can't use something you haven't...

    Of course you can't use something you haven't gained yet. However since it's not specified, the most logical timing for the weakened token to be put on the unit would be after the defense dice are...
  78. Replies
    12
    Views
    723

    Specifically, can you trigger tactical approach...

    Specifically, can you trigger tactical approach immediately from a weakened token that a unit gained by rolling a 1 against Baratheon Wardens Warhammer attack?
  79. Replies
    7
    Views
    1,767

    Any idea when the license would be up for...

    Any idea when the license would be up for renewal? That would be what might worry me. The spin off TV show however does provide some promise the ASOIAF continuing to be popular in the future which...
  80. Replies
    7
    Views
    1,767

    Talk to me about CMON

    I've been in a bit of a game limbo lately. I'm generally a competitive miniature gamer, I've played Warmachine and Guildball for the last 5 years, placing pretty well at some past Warmachine...
Results 1 to 80 of 82

Privacy Policy  |   Terms and Conditions  |   Contact Us  |   The Legion


Copyright © 2001-2018 CMON Inc.

-->