Search Results - CoolMiniOrNot Forums

Search:

Type: Posts; User: Hecaton

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    10
    Views
    716

    No, because it *was* targeted it just was not...

    No, because it *was* targeted it just was not affected.
  2. Replies
    10
    Views
    716

    RAW means "rules as written."

    RAW means "rules as written."
  3. As long as there's enough room, sure. Why...

    As long as there's enough room, sure. Why wouldn't you be able to?
  4. Replies
    10
    Views
    716

    It shouldn't matter whose turn it is.

    It shouldn't matter whose turn it is.
  5. Replies
    12
    Views
    729

    Uh, no. I TO tournaments and don't use that...

    Uh, no. I TO tournaments and don't use that poster as a resource.
  6. Replies
    12
    Views
    729

    I want a game dev to answer questions too. That's...

    I want a game dev to answer questions too. That's the whole point of this thread lol.
  7. Replies
    4
    Views
    258

    Nah, they'll just get mad at you for nitpicking...

    Nah, they'll just get mad at you for nitpicking and daring to ask that question.
  8. This is interesting because the rulebook doesn't...

    This is interesting because the rulebook doesn't imply alternating ability orders at all. A good candidate for an FAQ.
  9. Replies
    1
    Views
    130

    In English this would technically be ambiguous...

    In English this would technically be ambiguous but I'm pretty confident that it has to be enemy.
  10. Replies
    12
    Views
    729

    Rules exist to be nitpicked; in a few cases, they...

    Rules exist to be nitpicked; in a few cases, they just don't work as written. I get it that you're very interested in the social hierarchy of designers=>community middlemen=>lumpen masses, with the...
  11. Replies
    12
    Views
    729

    Nobody's answering rules questions

    Nobody official's answering rules questions here, we've had silence from CMON on this game for a while, Michael and Fabio haven't communicated in 6 months. I emailed CMON asking them who was...
  12. Replies
    1
    Views
    259

    They're definitely lost. Use the app, it's got...

    They're definitely lost. Use the app, it's got the updated versions.
  13. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    Which is tricky, because in previous iterations...

    Which is tricky, because in previous iterations of the rules they said you could do it in either order. And it's very relevant in some NCU's case - Melisandre, for example.
  14. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    Yes, I understand that nobody plays it that way,...

    Yes, I understand that nobody plays it that way, which is a problem, because we don't know how the designers intended it to work with effects like Catelyn's influence. If you point out that the...
  15. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    It triggers field control *and* Caitlyn's...

    It triggers field control *and* Caitlyn's influence. They both have the timing of "when a zone is claimed", and the active player's effects go first.
  16. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    Except Field Control's resolution itself is a...

    Except Field Control's resolution itself is a "when this zone is claimed" trigger. So if we assume that Influence, the Maneuever Zone, and Field control all have the same trigger, then the active...
  17. Replies
    1
    Views
    343

    Rules as written, it depends on the order. When...

    Rules as written, it depends on the order. When you check the scenario rule, it checks to see how many corpse piles are out, and if there's too many, whether from Remorseless Examples or itself, they...
  18. The issue is that Field Control doesn't even work...

    The issue is that Field Control doesn't even work as written, so we have to double-check everything involving it.
  19. [/LIST] I would say that a destroyed unit, by...

    [/LIST]

    I would say that a destroyed unit, by implication, has lost all of its ranks - otherwise it wouldn't be destroyed.


    Shield Wall only works when you're being attacked, and only blocks...
  20. Replies
    1
    Views
    178

    Despite the fact that orders are formatted the...

    Despite the fact that orders are formatted the exact same way as Tactics Cards, they do not follow the same targeting rules, which is very confusing. Yes, Quick Fire does not target the charging unit...
  21. Replies
    1
    Views
    181

    Page 17 of the rules lays out the attack...

    Page 17 of the rules lays out the attack sequence. Any ability, like Sentinel, that triggers "after a unit has been attacked" triggers during the "Attack Completed" step. So it is after the panic...
  22. Robb Stark, King in the North vs. Field Control

    Assuming that we muddle our way through Field Control's tortuous wording and assume that it works, is there any reason why it wouldn't completely negate the new Robb's ability? You can only use it...
  23. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    Why would you think that? The rulebook uses the...

    Why would you think that? The rulebook uses the language "when you claim the zone" for the effect of the zone itself too.
  24. Replies
    12
    Views
    628

    Catelyn Stark vs. Field Control

    Can Catelyn Stark resolve her Influence after the effects of the Maneuver (horse) zone to remove the Weakened token imposed by Field Control?
  25. Replies
    1
    Views
    225

    Yes and it's off the fucking chain. Hope you have...

    Yes and it's off the fucking chain. Hope you have auto wounds or can deal more than 6 hits.
  26. Thread: Orders

    by Hecaton
    Replies
    6
    Views
    398

    So yeah, if you have war cry from multiple...

    So yeah, if you have war cry from multiple sources you can target an enemy unit with it more than once, from both your units with war cry. Why wouldn't you be able to?

    Now, if you have a unit with...
  27. Replies
    1
    Views
    276

    I mean I blame Asmodee, but to each their own.

    I mean I blame Asmodee, but to each their own.
  28. Thread: Orders

    by Hecaton
    Replies
    6
    Views
    398

    Could you give an example? Because it depends on...

    Could you give an example? Because it depends on what you mean by "affected" and "sources."
  29. Player A's "after retreat" action. The Retreat is...

    Player A's "after retreat" action. The Retreat is entirely contained within resolving Player A's original "after an attack is resolved" trigger. Once the retreat is entirely resolved (including...
  30. Correct. You could use Sacrifice for the Cause...

    Correct. You could use Sacrifice for the Cause immediately after your opponent plays Coordination Tactics, though, before they resolve it.
  31. Incorrect. By the time Coordination Tactics...

    Incorrect. By the time Coordination Tactics resolves, the "start of turn" trigger has already passed. It provides a specific exception for Orders on Coordination Tactics, but Sabotage and Subvert is...
  32. It's a grey area, and it'd be nice to get some...

    It's a grey area, and it'd be nice to get some confirmation on it, but my take would be it doesn't work because you can't remove the model in question. The "Camp Followers" ability would still...
  33. Whoops, yup, was confusing it for the NCU. Yeah,...

    Whoops, yup, was confusing it for the NCU. Yeah, it will copy.
  34. Influence abilities are not copied by...

    Influence abilities are not copied by Coordination Tactics. They're not an ability on the unit.

    EDIT: this is not relevant to this case.
  35. Doesn't apply in this case.

    Doesn't apply in this case.
  36. Or a Targ player could use it when they claim a...

    Or a Targ player could use it when they claim a zone. I might see it happen.
  37. Honestly that card is too powerful anyway.

    Honestly that card is too powerful anyway.
  38. My point is that it's CMON overall who bears the...

    My point is that it's CMON overall who bears the responsibility, not anyone community-facing.
  39. I don't think CMON is paying the designers enough...

    I don't think CMON is paying the designers enough to take the time. I actually support that - I wouldn't want them doing work for free.
  40. I was aware of those but was ignoring them for...

    I was aware of those but was ignoring them for simplicity's sake. But yes, that would be more reasonable than the current BS we have now.
  41. Replies
    1
    Views
    254

    No, because they have the same name for the...

    No, because they have the same name for the keyword (Horrific). There's a tactics card that creates special corpse piles that I think the Weeper and a version of Dany has. Those corpse piles have a...
  42. That's exactly what we're saying. The card is...

    That's exactly what we're saying. The card is written wrong.
  43. Incorrect. Endless Horde and the zone itself have...

    Incorrect. Endless Horde and the zone itself have the same trigger ("when a zone is claimed"), so they both resolve before Field Control does.

    If things were as you described Influence effects...
  44. Replies
    4
    Views
    546

    So, what? You're not being clear, unfortunately. ...

    So, what? You're not being clear, unfortunately.

    The answer is 1. You can only use each ability once per trigger. And at that point Selyse & Shireen cannot save them.
  45. Replies
    4
    Views
    546

    Remember that morale tests are not panic tests,...

    Remember that morale tests are not panic tests, but panic tests are a subset of morale tests. If you fail a morale test, you're not destroyed; the destruction is still the original impetus.
  46. Replies
    2
    Views
    431

    The "if any" is probably superfluous, but it's a...

    The "if any" is probably superfluous, but it's a matter of the designers twisting the rules to make things like NW crossbows overpowered with their order in the last revision, and the consequences...
  47. Replies
    1
    Views
    357

    The player playing the card. They control the...

    The player playing the card. They control the effect.
  48. Thread: Giant wounds

    by Hecaton
    Replies
    1
    Views
    377

    Yes. But keep in mind any effect which does...

    Yes. But keep in mind any effect which does wounds (Precision etc) will just deal a wound to them.
  49. Replies
    1
    Views
    397

    I'd like clarification here too.

    I'd like clarification here too.
  50. That's a great question we could use an answer to.

    That's a great question we could use an answer to.
  51. Wasn't resolved in the latest update. Bumping for...

    Wasn't resolved in the latest update. Bumping for visibility.
  52. The issue is that at the time the trigger...

    The issue is that at the time the trigger happens, the unit is off the board, and therefore isn't within long range.
  53. RAW it doesn't work.

    RAW it doesn't work.
  54. Replies
    1
    Views
    345

    As long as, when your turn starts, your opponent...

    As long as, when your turn starts, your opponent still has unactivated units, yes.
  55. Replies
    7
    Views
    668

    Wrong. It's in the rulebook. All orders are...

    Wrong. It's in the rulebook. All orders are considered to target the unit they originate from.
  56. Nah, when a unit attacks you still have to...

    Nah, when a unit attacks you still have to resolve all triggers, like Horrific Visage.
  57. Replies
    7
    Views
    668

    Yes, you can stop the unit's own order with it.

    Yes, you can stop the unit's own order with it.
  58. Yeah that's not clear at all. It could use a...

    Yeah that's not clear at all. It could use a clarification.
  59. The latter. For the same reason that if you play...

    The latter. For the same reason that if you play What is Dead May Never Die on a unit when it dies from damage it can still die from panic.
  60. Another one is Mag the Mighty's on death effect...

    Another one is Mag the Mighty's on death effect vs. Horrific Visage.

    Alisser, I definitely disagree with your take.
  61. The rulebook agrees with me and not you.

    The rulebook agrees with me and not you.
  62. It's an NPE for newbies to be told that effects like Final Strike don't work on death

    What the title says. Not being able to use Final Strike and similar effects when a tray is wiped sits pretty poorly with every new player I've seen.
  63. That's all well and good, but the effect of the...

    That's all well and good, but the effect of the zone itself resolves before Field Control does, but can be resolved after the active player's replacement effects.

    You've got the timing overall...
  64. I agree with your "replace a zone twice"...

    I agree with your "replace a zone twice" statement, but the problem is that the actual zone resolves before Field Control does. You resolve all of the active player's "when a zone is claimed"...
  65. I appreciate the thought but that doesn't match...

    I appreciate the thought but that doesn't match up with how we know the zone is supposed to be resolved.
  66. Replies
    18
    Views
    8,171

    As of the current update, I am seeing two...

    As of the current update, I am seeing two bugs/problems:

    1. For each faction, one of their commanders is not showing up in the "tactics cards" menu. I've confirmed this for Free Folk and Bara at...
  67. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    You said the exact opposite on your last post....

    You said the exact opposite on your last post. What are you getting at?
  68. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    No, if the attacker isn't engaged with the...

    No, if the attacker isn't engaged with the defender at that point, they cannot receive hits. It's part of why this card is written improperly - if the defender is killed by the attack, they cannot...
  69. And just to elaborate here, when you follow the...

    And just to elaborate here, when you follow the resolution of effects in order, like we're told to in a bunch of other rules sources, the effect just doesn't work. How do you think players should...
  70. Replies
    2
    Views
    807

    The two strongest commanders for Lannisters are...

    The two strongest commanders for Lannisters are Roose and Tyrion, from the largest set of player data we have.
  71. Replies
    7
    Views
    545

    If it's not in the rulebook you can't expect...

    If it's not in the rulebook you can't expect players to play it that way. Different people's "common sense" may mean different things, and usually amounts to players trying to force their...
  72. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    Aight, whatever, you clearly don't understand...

    Aight, whatever, you clearly don't understand what I'm saying.
  73. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    They used the word "targeted" in OP.

    They used the word "targeted" in OP.
  74. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    As I mentioned, and this is in the rulebook,...

    As I mentioned, and this is in the rulebook, anybody mentioned in the bolded trigger section of the card is considered targeted.
  75. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,056

    Anybody mentioned in the trigger (The first...

    Anybody mentioned in the trigger (The first bolded sentence followed by the colon) is a target of a tactics card (but not an order). So since the enemy attacking unit is mentioned in the trigger, it...
  76. Yes, and my point is that the language should be...

    Yes, and my point is that the language should be cleaned up in the FAQ/errata, because I'm 99% sure that wasn't the intent. There's an issue in the sense that the wording is sloppy.
  77. The use of "1+, 2+" etc implies they're...

    The use of "1+, 2+" etc implies they're cumulative.
  78. I think we still need a clarification on this....

    I think we still need a clarification on this. It's pretty fuzzy.
  79. Nah, the timing issue is still in question.

    Nah, the timing issue is still in question.
  80. RAW Field Control doesn't work on opposing NCUs

    Might be worth a FAQ entry/errata - RAW, both the tactics zone itself and Field Control have trigger timing of "when an NCU claims a zone." When resolving simultaneous effects, the active player's...
  81. No, I'm talking about the attack granted by Last...

    No, I'm talking about the attack granted by Last Stand.
  82. Neither of those. Order is: 1. NCU claims zone...

    Neither of those. Order is:
    1. NCU claims zone
    2. Targ player plays Field Control, which does nothing to the board but changes how the active player's action plays out.
    3. Active player resolves...
  83. You still control the effect; you're choosing the...

    You still control the effect; you're choosing the targeting. It's just changed to be a shitty, shitty effect.

    I don't think you're being super clear with what you're trying to say, but the way you...
  84. So because Influence effects are simultaneous...

    So because Influence effects are simultaneous with the actual zone ability, the active player gets to choose the order they resolve in. This means that you, as the active player, can choose to have...
  85. Welp, bursting their bubble might be a rough...

    Welp, bursting their bubble might be a rough time. But he's still very good.
  86. It does none of those things. You never get the...

    It does none of those things. You never get the effect, and you don't actually occupy the space. You just count as controlling the zone for other effects.
  87. When does a unit affected by Last Stand die?

    Is it:

    1. Immediately after the attack
    2. As a "when this attack is completed" trigger
    3. After "when this attack is completed" triggers, but before Surge Forth?
    4. After Surge Forth?
  88. Well you can physically contact a tray in an arc...

    Well you can physically contact a tray in an arc other than where you started, but you have to align to the arc you started in. But I guess you formally "contact" the enemy in the arc you started,...
  89. Replies
    3
    Views
    527

    Keep in mind that the wound suffered through...

    Keep in mind that the wound suffered through panic are part of the attack, so you can play WIDMND when a unit gets wiped due to panic.
  90. I'm guessing they're busy with the kickstarter...

    I'm guessing they're busy with the kickstarter atm.
  91. Replies
    4
    Views
    552

    It's based on the unit itself. Attachments don't...

    It's based on the unit itself. Attachments don't count unless they have the "Affiliation" ability.
  92. Replies
    0
    Views
    226

    Kingsguard Banners and redeployment

    When the Kingsguard unit is redeployed (as in the case of Here We Stand's scenario rules and others), do they show up with a fresh supply of banners?
  93. Replies
    2
    Views
    448

    That's correct. And that's a big part of why...

    That's correct. And that's a big part of why Giants aren't worth running.
  94. Feinting Maneuver & Charging from the Front

    What does this card mean by "contact"? Can I charge a unit from the front, but actually touch bases in their side arc, and then align to the rear?
  95. Thread: Surge Forth

    by Hecaton
    Replies
    1
    Views
    264

    Yes and yes.

    Yes and yes.
  96. Replies
    1
    Views
    217

    Active player's effect resolves first, ergo...

    Active player's effect resolves first, ergo active player has the first turn to re-roll.
  97. Replies
    2
    Views
    227

    Thanks! I know it was changed wrt Redcloaks, but...

    Thanks! I know it was changed wrt Redcloaks, but didn't know it was a general thing.
  98. Replies
    2
    Views
    227

    Aeron Damphair and Charge

    We know that Redcloaks consider a charge a single action for their ability; is this true for Aeron Damphair's Influence ability too?
  99. Replies
    2
    Views
    272

    They both have to be on the same unit.

    They both have to be on the same unit.
  100. Replies
    4
    Views
    290

    That's cool, those should probably be changed...

    That's cool, those should probably be changed then.
  101. Replies
    4
    Views
    290

    That doesn't answer my question, so it's not much...

    That doesn't answer my question, so it's not much help.
  102. Replies
    4
    Views
    299

    Yeah, you might be right. I'd still love to get...

    Yeah, you might be right. I'd still love to get an official word on this.
  103. Replies
    4
    Views
    290

    Benjen vs. Robb Stark's Hit and Run

    Is Benjen Stark's version of Hit and Run meant to have the same requirement that Robb's was, where it requires you to begin the Turn engaged with the Defender to be able to Retreat? Seems like a...
  104. No it's not. I noted that RoH have worse...

    No it's not. I noted that RoH have worse attachment options and a deck that doesn't work as well compared to Screamers; I'm looking at the holistic situation.

    The rest of your argument says that...
  105. Replies
    1
    Views
    213

    The token goes on the unit that used it, say you...

    The token goes on the unit that used it, say you copy War Cry over with CT - you can use it on the unit that only temporarily has it, and it won't affect the use of the ability on the first unit.
    ...
  106. No, it's really not ok. If they explicitly said...

    No, it's really not ok. If they explicitly said that Baratheon was an underpowered faction in the rulebook or on the box, that'd be one thing, but people are buying into this game with a certain...
  107. I coulda swore I remembered it, but the search...

    I coulda swore I remembered it, but the search function wasn't returning crap.
  108. Lord Tywin's Mad Dog and extra activations

    When the Uncontrolled Rage ability on Gregor Clegane, Lord Tywin's Mad Dog is used, does that charge count ad his action for his activation?

    EDIT: Already answered, derp.
  109. Replies
    3
    Views
    386

    It's not that they're mutually exclusive - if you...

    It's not that they're mutually exclusive - if you play it like Diversionary Tactics you can't ever legally place the corpse pile, since the "Short Range" mentioned on the card is, by implication, in...
  110. Replies
    4
    Views
    299

    What makes you think that? If that were true,...

    What makes you think that? If that were true, wouldn't Mission 4 be "Each time..."?
  111. Turncoat and Regroup and Reform interaction

    Player A is a Free Folk player and Player B is a Lannister Player. It is player A's turn. They play Regroup and Reform on two of their units, one of which contains a Turncoat placed by the Lannister...
  112. Replies
    4
    Views
    299

    Scoring Missions more than once

    For mission cards that you could conceivably score multiple times, is it possible? For example, for mission 2, do you score a point each time an enemy claims the Combat or Maneuver zone do you gain a...
  113. Regroup and Reform and Turncoat interaction

    Meant to post this in the rules q's section.
  114. Replies
    0
    Views
    154

    Mission 10 and center objectives

    Is a centrally-placed objective considered to be on both sides of the table, or neither, for the purposes of Mission 10?
  115. In older FAQs there were comments that if you had...

    In older FAQs there were comments that if you had a choice about *when* to trigger an ability, it targets. Because you could choose to use it when unit charges and not when another does.
  116. Replies
    8
    Views
    796

    Once per round or once total, if it's in play for...

    Once per round or once total, if it's in play for 2 rounds?
  117. Replies
    8
    Views
    796

    I know *this* isn't the case. It's not...

    I know *this* isn't the case.



    It's not "once per round." It never says that on the card. It says "once this round."
  118. I'm not saying it doesn't target the Xbowmen. I'm...

    I'm not saying it doesn't target the Xbowmen. I'm saying it *does* target the charging unit, if Eddard targets.
  119. Replies
    8
    Views
    796

    No, it happens "once this round." Which is a...

    No, it happens "once this round." Which is a different statement. Like I said, it's unclear, we should wait for some official word.
  120. The point is that if Eddard Stark is considered...

    The point is that if Eddard Stark is considered to target, then you'd be wrong about Ready! Aim! Fire! (assuming the ruling follows some sort of overarching logic and is not meant to be arbitrary).
  121. Replies
    8
    Views
    796

    The use of "this round" in the text of mission 9...

    The use of "this round" in the text of mission 9 inplies that it will only be in effect for a single round (at a time). We nerf a clarification on what's intended from the rules team.
  122. Replies
    1
    Views
    235

    Mission 6 question

    Does a unit have to be entirely within the enemy deployment zone to score Mission 6, or just with a tiny sliver of their base inside?
  123. Replies
    8
    Views
    796

    Dark Wings Dark Words scoring Question

    The game mode states that the mission cards are drawn at the start of the game, but don't cycle the first time until the start of the 3rd round - so potentially some objectives might stick around for...
  124. Better then pretending there's no problem, like...

    Better then pretending there's no problem, like your cartoon implied.
  125. How the heck does Eddard Stark target? By that...

    How the heck does Eddard Stark target? By that logic Ready! Aim! Fire! should target, and we know that doesn't.
  126. Do you think that balance is not a good design...

    Do you think that balance is not a good design goal?
  127. Replies
    6
    Views
    317

    The first effect is controlled by the Lannister...

    The first effect is controlled by the Lannister player, the other effect is controlled by their opponent.
  128. Replies
    6
    Views
    317

    No, I'm right. Read the card. I guarantee you're...

    No, I'm right. Read the card. I guarantee you're misinterpreting whatever you're reading. "Controller" means something different and specific, but I think the language barrier is going to prevent me...
  129. Replies
    11
    Views
    983

    These two statements are in contradiction to each...

    These two statements are in contradiction to each other.
  130. Replies
    1
    Views
    769

    So the first thing to (unfortunately) keep in...

    So the first thing to (unfortunately) keep in mind is that targeting works differently for Orders and Tactics Cards. For Tactics Cards, anything mentioned in bold before the colon (the trigger) is...
  131. Riders of Highgarden are strictly worse Dothraki Screamers

    Unless fighting against Armor 2+ opponents *from the front*, Dothraki Screamers will out-damage Riders of Highgarden, as well as be more durable. What's more, they have worse attachment options, and...
  132. Replies
    6
    Views
    317

    The Joffrey NCU specifically says on the card...

    The Joffrey NCU specifically says on the card that your opponent gets to target and choose one of your units on the card.

    The difference to keep in mind with Turncoat is that once the game...
  133. Thread: Expert Duelist

    by Hecaton
    Replies
    1
    Views
    313

    Yup, because it says "1 additional wound" it's...

    Yup, because it says "1 additional wound" it's considered to be a wound inflicted by the attack.
  134. Replies
    12
    Views
    1,469

    Still waiting for someone to say anything in the...

    Still waiting for someone to say anything in the face of this lol
  135. Replies
    11
    Views
    983

    When the ruling is in contravention to the text...

    When the ruling is in contravention to the text of the card it's worth asking. Is the text in error?
  136. Replies
    1
    Views
    416

    You can resolve the effects in either order, as...

    You can resolve the effects in either order, as the active player, so it's possible to attach Ygritte to the unit after it is brought onto the table.
  137. Cool, thanks.

    Cool, thanks.
  138. Would be nice. I'm hoping for an official word on...

    Would be nice. I'm hoping for an official word on it so we can put it to rest.
  139. Replies
    3
    Views
    705

    The rules call them "effects" but never abilities.

    The rules call them "effects" but never abilities.
  140. Gregor Clegane - Lord Tywin's Mad Dog vs. Cavalry

    Does the Clegane attachment's charge use up its action for its activation? If so, what makes it different from the free maneuver that cavalry get? There's a player in my playgroup who's insisting you...
  141. Replies
    4
    Views
    455

    Olenna's ability comes off as a specific...

    Olenna's ability comes off as a specific exception to the rule that you can't target units off the board.
  142. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,427

    I'm actually not so sure this is intentional;...

    I'm actually not so sure this is intentional; previous FAQ rulings indicated that units mentioned in the trigger for orders were targeted too.
  143. Replies
    13
    Views
    1,427

    Ok, now I'm confused. For Tactics Cards, the unit...

    Ok, now I'm confused. For Tactics Cards, the unit that triggers them is considered a target - but this is not true of Orders?
  144. Nah I just mean like... players' hands aren't...

    Nah I just mean like... players' hands aren't accurate to sub-mm distances, and that's what's required to adjudicate contact in this case.
  145. This seems like a pretty egregious balance issue...

    This seems like a pretty egregious balance issue lol
  146. How do you adjudicate that when trays are...

    How do you adjudicate that when trays are potentially jostled or moved or on a slightly uneven table to be .00001 mm out?
  147. Replies
    5
    Views
    650

    Great! Thanks.

    Great! Thanks.
  148. So when do you align enemies as described under...

    So when do you align enemies as described under the "contacting multiple enemies," sidebar on p.16? Before aligning to your charge target? How does that work?
  149. Replies
    5
    Views
    650

    I'm asking if it's generalizable.

    I'm asking if it's generalizable.
  150. Replies
    5
    Views
    650

    "Before Rolling Attack Dice" triggers

    Should these be read as "Before Determining Attack Dice?" Like for example a unit of Rose Knights has 8 wounds remaining and makes a melee attack. Does it roll 5 dice because it gained a wound back...
  151. When is a charge considered to be successful?

    Specifically with respect to the "Engaging Multiple Enemies" sidebar on page 16 of the rulebook. Does it happen after the "Roll Charge Distance and Move Attacker" step, the "Align with Enemy" step,...
  152. Replies
    3
    Views
    503

    Why wouldn't you just rule it the other way,...

    Why wouldn't you just rule it the other way, though? Why should moving an attachment from 1 unit to the other result in a net loss of a wound from a game experience perspective? Why not just apply...
  153. Replies
    6
    Views
    1,502

    Better solution would be to update giant unit...

    Better solution would be to update giant unit cards with an ability that says "whenever this unit takes wounds, it takes half that many wounds, rounding down, instead" and get rid of their existing...
  154. Replies
    2
    Views
    502

    Hilarious with Endless Horde if it works that way.

    Hilarious with Endless Horde if it works that way.
  155. Replies
    4
    Views
    2,208

    Sticky: This is a good next step.

    This is a good next step.
  156. How long we will have to wait for a Mammoth fix?

    The minis are sweet, and were incredibly anticipated on my part, but the rules after the revision fell incredibly flat. If they're not going to be playable for like a year+ I might as well sell off...
  157. Do Night's Watch attached tactics cards apply immediately?

    Wrong subforum
  158. Replies
    4
    Views
    3,170

    And now he doesn't buff giants. Giants have way...

    And now he doesn't buff giants. Giants have way too much skornergy (antisynergy) in the 2021 update IMO.
  159. Replies
    18
    Views
    8,171

    The points deduction for running all 3 dragons...

    The points deduction for running all 3 dragons and the Mother of Dragons version of Dany isn't being applied correctly. More precisely, it's not being applied at all.
  160. Replies
    4
    Views
    3,170

    Giants are actually nice with him. One of the...

    Giants are actually nice with him. One of the main abilities he has is he can go fish his cards out of the deck, thus thinning your deck.
  161. Replies
    15
    Views
    5,561

    So Shinall admitted that Starks are overtuned....

    So Shinall admitted that Starks are overtuned. Seems like I was on about the truth when I was talking about this.
  162. Replies
    15
    Views
    5,561

    The tournament in question was slanted heavily...

    The tournament in question was slanted heavily towards Lannister.



    No, I don't think he (or you) are following. I'd imagine that if there were more tournament results you'd still say the...
  163. Replies
    15
    Views
    5,561

    If you understood statistics, you'd also know...

    If you understood statistics, you'd also know that smaller groups lead to more variance, and so your comment about neutrals is meaningless.

    The real question is, does Starks w/ max wolves...
  164. Replies
    15
    Views
    5,561

    My understanding was that the last big Euro...

    My understanding was that the last big Euro tournament had 6/10 of the top 10 being Stark, 5 of those being lists abusing cheap Wolves to get more activations, and there was only 1 Lannister in the...
  165. Replies
    15
    Views
    5,561

    So are Starks going to get nerfed?

    They seem quite OP at the moment, and the last big tournament before the pandemic hit was overwhelmingly tilted towards Starks.
  166. Replies
    3
    Views
    2,986

    How to use Trappers?

    So I've been playing a bit, and the units that I've found the easiest to use have been Raiders, Followers/Champions of bone, and Giants. I want to branch out a little; how do people use Trappers?...
  167. There are effects that blank them but Ygritte is...

    There are effects that blank them but Ygritte is great for dealing with Walder.
  168. At least bears will make it much easier to get 2...

    At least bears will make it much easier to get 2 units in melee with 1.
  169. Is it just me or is the Free Folk tactics deck among the worst?

    Many of the cards are *very* situational and require more setup than other factions' card decks - do you guys think this limits the factions' potential, since CMON said they don't want to errata card...
  170. Replies
    16
    Views
    5,852

    I'm guessing the next two are Greyjoy and...

    I'm guessing the next two are Greyjoy and Martell. But I hope they take their time with it, all the current factions need some love on the supply chain side.
  171. Always run Ygritte to protect the big lads.

    Always run Ygritte to protect the big lads.
  172. For an "elite" list you're gonna want FoB (or...

    For an "elite" list you're gonna want FoB (or lots of giants).
  173. It means having an average cost of 4/activation...

    It means having an average cost of 4/activation in your army... that's low, even for Free Folk. I'd be interested to see how Badger breaks down listbuilding if he thinks 10 activations is important...
  174. WTF do you mean "only 9 activations"? That's...

    WTF do you mean "only 9 activations"? That's quite a few. In 50 point games, sure, we can start talking 10+
  175. Replies
    5
    Views
    1,955

    When to run 3 NCUs?

    It seems like running 2 or 3 NCUs is what people do. Whay affects your guys' decision making process in this regard? When do you run 2, when do you run 3?
  176. Tyrell might have been its own faction at one...

    Tyrell might have been its own faction at one point.
  177. Yeah, though part of the problem is if every...

    Yeah, though part of the problem is if every neutral unit costs, say, 1 point more than it would if it were in-faction, then in a merc army, running lots of troops becomes the main option, just the...
  178. Replies
    2
    Views
    3,637

    You know what they could add that would kick ass?...

    You know what they could add that would kick ass? A "for beginners" button on the main screen that'd have tutorial videos and suggested starting army lists for all of the faction starters.
  179. Replies
    4
    Views
    3,308

    Units to double up on?

    I'm a new Free Folk player, and I've got 2 copies of the starter, and 1 of everything else except the cave dweller savages, which I'll probably get soon. I wanted to ask the community what units...
  180. I think we can agree on that, but in a...

    I think we can agree on that, but in a Neutral-only faction they should have something to make up for that. If the Neutral Tactics Deck was OP to make up for intentionally throttled units, that would...
  181. A poll is not a particularly effective way of...

    A poll is not a particularly effective way of getting objective data. Most people are going to fall into the "my faction is underpowered, factions mine has an advantage against are balanced, factions...
  182. What other major tournaments have Neutrals...

    What other major tournaments have Neutrals performed poorly at?
  183. Well pre 1.5.1 Boltons won LVO, didn't they?

    Well pre 1.5.1 Boltons won LVO, didn't they?
  184. Win At All Costs.

    Win At All Costs.
  185. From my perspective, it looks like a bunch of...

    From my perspective, it looks like a bunch of WAAC players upset the meta is now more balanced.
  186. Replies
    14
    Views
    5,377

    This. Competitive games need rules updates to...

    This. Competitive games need rules updates to adjust to things. This is a good thing; if it happens about once a year, that's fine.
  187. Replies
    8
    Views
    2,073

    Cool, thanks for your insight.

    Cool, thanks for your insight.
  188. Replies
    8
    Views
    2,073

    Thanks for the input, guys. Do you think Frey is...

    Thanks for the input, guys. Do you think Frey is pushing people to run more spammy, less elite armies so as not to provide juicy targets for his ability?
  189. Replies
    8
    Views
    2,073

    Neutral Autoincludes?

    Just started this game, and I'm playing Free Folk, so can't run neutral units. I've heard that Walder Frey and Varys are very commonly run as the NCUs of choice, since Walder Frey can shut down...
Results 1 to 189 of 189

Privacy Policy  |   Terms and Conditions  |   Contact Us  |   The Legion


Copyright © 2001-2018 CMON Inc.

-->