I agree, it shouldn't be below table top average...but here are a few things that might be keeping the score down. 1. Can't see the face properly, the pose is awkward. 2. Too much white space on the pic..crop that stuff out.
Ok, my head is exploding. Why is this a 3.9? Colours are nice, paint is neat, shading is simple but effective. I'd be happy to put this mini on my table for gaming. Very solid 5, maybe even a six.