Clean work on the grey armour, and the yellow shoulder trim really pops against it. Four more to go is the home stretch, looking forward to seeing the whole squad lined up together.
Honestly I prefer a conversion like this to a new kit. The pose has more character, and the heraldry colours tie the rider and the pegasus together nicely. Did you sculpt the wing feathers or are they from another kit?
I like the lived-in direction a lot. One thing that helped me with faded cloth was mixing a little of the base colour into a dusty beige for the top highlights instead of going lighter with white, then a very thin brown glaze over the lower folds so it reads as grime rather than shadow.
The exposure looks good to me, but I would try a slightly smaller aperture so the whole figure stays in focus from the base to the face. A plain gradient backdrop instead of the busy background would also keep the eye on the paint job.
I had the same trouble with glossy hair. What finally worked was moving both lights further away and bouncing them off white card instead of pointing them at the mini, plus a final coat of matte varnish thinned a little so it dried evenly.
Seconding the white storage bin idea. I used a frosted one with two cheap 5000K desk lamps on either side and a strip of grey card curving up the back, and it got rid of most of the hard shadows for well under twenty dollars.