I'm very much against inflated scores myself, but I think Greenstuffy's being a bit too hard here... OK, there's definitely room for improvemente, but the contours are clean and I can see a brave attempt at detail (the guy with the hammers had his eyes painted, for example).
As for the glossiness, it seems to me that these figs have been painted with enamels... and if it's so, they're done very well, since it's so hard to work with them at this scale! I'm giving them a 5, mainly because of the hammer guy (he looks "tabletop-worthy" to me!)
Legolas is to you what these minis are for me to look at....sory, but there's a whole lotta work to be done! Try shadings and highlights to be more spread, have some single photos, please. This photo make me give you this poor grade. Sorry, I'm sure you can do better than this, avoid also the glossy varnish!!!
Vote
