fishing for feedback

treide

New member
I waited until these hit around 60 votes before asking, but would appreciate any comments on my two latest submissions.

Bevo the Minotaur:

http://www.coolminiornot.com/137012

Gnome Illusionist:

http://www.coolminiornot.com/137011

The gnome is an old TSR mini, but I am not sure who manufactured the minotaur or how old it is.

Thanks!
 

Ogrebane

Active member
The gnome is very good. I would say in the 7s somewhere. The pic is a little out of focus and might hold it down alittle. Also it would look better on a bigger base (IMHO) The painting is very good tho as is the color selection
The minitor is also in the 7s and could use rebasing othe rthan that the painting is very good.
 

hubbabubba

New member
Voted on both, 6.5\'s IMHO, I don\'t think they\'ll go much higher due to the quality of these old sculpts.
Agree with the comment about the gnomes character, but there seems to be alot of difference in the quality of your work on say his hat and face, compared to the cloak and breeches.
Nice to see these ol\' mini\'s, thanks
 

treide

New member
@ogrebane - Thanks for the comments; always appreciated. I have a question about \"rebasing\". For minis with \"built-in\" bases, what is the best technique for rebasing them? The few times I have done it, I have just glued the original base onto a new one, and then attempted to build up the ground so that the original base blends in. The other option I have considered is removing the old base, but I don\'t really know the best technique for doing that without damaging the mini.

@hubbabubba - Thanks! I would like to someday paint an old mini well enough that it will rate with more modern minis, but that may just be wishfull thinking. I have seen others pull it off - IG88\'s dragons and some of SaxonAngel\'s stuff come to mind, and I am sure there are others. I agree the cloak didn\'t turn out as well as I would have liked, but I couldn\'t think of anything else to do with it.
 

mickc22

Granddad!
I\'m not much of a fan of sculpted on bases myself I usually remove the bulk of them with clippers finishing off under the feet with the dremel. If it\'s particularly thick a jewellers saw would work well
 

D.O.Error

New member
My brother had that Minotaur figure back in the 80s. Came in a set with an efreet and some other monsters. It was probably made by Grenadier, since that’s what most of our figs were then, but I\'m not certain.
 

Wren

Member
How I handle integral bases depends on the base and how I want to base the figure. The easiest is to do an outdoors base. I glue the figure down to a plastic base, schlop CA glue all around it, then dip it into a bin of mixed size gravel (railroad ballast). Let it sit a minute, then another layer of CA glue and another dip until the edge matches up, then a layer that builds onto the base to blend the two in.

You can also use GS or wood putty or a number of other things to build up around the integral base and blend it in. GS or similar putties are probably the best answer if your integral base has a texture like cobblestones or planks that you want to match.

If I\'m doing the kind of base where I need to work up the base separately and then attach the figure, then I use clippers, dremel and files, and lots of time.

I have to admit I think you\'d be unlikely to hit high scores with the older sculpts. Dragons are a bit of an exception, they were always larger and allowing for more room to sculpt in detail, and there are a lot of dragon fans. A lot of voters really do vote \'cool mini or not\', not cool paint job or not, so for most people, their opinions of the sculpt is a fairly significant factor in what they vote. Though there are some folks who appreciate the older sculpts and that it sometimes takes more effort to paint them well and score higher.

I agree SaxonAngel\'s work on older sculpts is great. I believe it also scores a little lower than her work in the same time period with more modern sculpts. Also much of it is from a year ago or more, and average scores do drop a little each year as people push the envelope of what\'s possible. I\'m not sure even SaxonAngel would get the same scores if she posted those minis today.

That\'s not to say I think you shouldn\'t work on the older sculpts, you do good work on them and it seems like you\'re having fun! You could try a newer sculpt every now and then just to see what kind of ratings and comments you get when sculpt is less of a factor.
 

treide

New member
Thanks for all the comments, folks!

I have mainly been \"practicing\" on the older ones, but maybe I\'ll tackle some of my newer minis soon.
 
Back To Top
Top