Originally posted by No Such Agency
Call me cynical but I\'d be willing to bet that a lot of groups vocally opposing child pornography are fronting for people who really want to criminalize ALL porn, including that containing 100% consenting adults. And that just makes my free-speech-o-meter go woop-woop-woop.
Okay, you\'re cynical. You\'re also correct.
One year ago in August the FBI re-initiated an \"anti-porn\" investigatory branch. Their target is \"manufacturers and purveyors of pornography\" -- not child porn, not bestiality, not porn already illegal under US law. Consensual pornography between consensual adults that they, the FBI, feel is obscene.
In addition, two of the previous child-pornography bills to come before the US congress would have made it illegal for any actual or “fictional” child-pornography to be distributed. That includes photos of 40 year-old women claiming to be teens. The bill only lost because it would have included, I kid you not, “Romeo & Juliet” (13/14 years old), the book “Lolita” for obvious reasons, and any other work of fiction that may be construed to contain child-pornography.
Child-pornography is a real and legitimate issue. It is a horrible, heinous crime and anyone engaging it should be dealt with in the harshest possible manner available to their government. But the question becomes where does it stop?
A very dear friend of mine spent time in jail for owning a copy of a 1970s book for children on anatomy. It was a gift from his mother when he was a child. In it are photos of people in non-provocative photos fully nude – front, sides and back of a man, woman, boy and girl. It is, after all, an anatomy book. It is also now illegal to own under US law. My friend was finally acquitted but only after a harsh investigation (cleared on all counts) and having his name on the front page of the local paper… which prompted him to move and leave his job of 20 years.
Now he advocates for families in similar situations. This includes parents who have lost their children because they had photos of the kids playing in the bathtub sitting on their mantle. There are similar situations – but that one is my favorite. I have yet to meet a parent that doesn’t have photos of their kids playing in the tub. Turns out it is okay to have them but not to display them.
Normally I wouldn’t make a post to something like this, but I felt compelled to respond.
This is a real problem. We need real solutions.
Unfortunately I don’t have one to share. I honestly, truly wish that I did.