alextheartist
New member
http://www.coolminiornot.com/209799
I think its pretty underrated, although the voting has just started..
I think its pretty underrated, although the voting has just started..
Underrated or what?
- Thread starter alextheartist
- Start date
Gilvan Blight
New member
7.3 when I looked, that doesn\'t seem underrated to me. Mainly do to the fact I think there are more space marine minis on this site then anything else. It\'s hard to find them still cool and interesting even if painted very well.
It\'s interesting to see one done in metallics as you don\'t see that very often but I found that the colours weren\'t consistant. Bright in some areas and dull in others. Due to being metallics there\'s a good chance this is mainly a lighting issue, but I can\'t really tell.
It\'s interesting to see one done in metallics as you don\'t see that very often but I found that the colours weren\'t consistant. Bright in some areas and dull in others. Due to being metallics there\'s a good chance this is mainly a lighting issue, but I can\'t really tell.
alextheartist
New member
People havent bothered to look at the details, such as the freehand on the shoulder arrow, decent blacks, decent osl, nice base and fairly good metalics. IMo should be at least 8
Alex
Alex
tidoco2222
Active member
Don\'t get me started I just put a new one on today and i know it is not a top scorer but I am sure it deserves more than 6.3 which it is currently getting after 20 votes. I am afraid that the voting on this site is starting to be hard to believe.
ScottRadom
Shogun of Saskatchewan
I feel it\'s an 8-9 model. I gave it a 9. Lovely work, I can\'t imagine an entire army done that way, it\'d blow my eyeballs out!
I think I\'m usually treated pretty fairly around here. I juts put a model up and I was hoping for a 7.5 but I think it\'s current score of signifigantly less is more accurate. Pic\'s and a bunch of stuff bring scores down for most. I think 95% of the models on the site would score about half to a full point more in real life.
I think I\'m usually treated pretty fairly around here. I juts put a model up and I was hoping for a 7.5 but I think it\'s current score of signifigantly less is more accurate. Pic\'s and a bunch of stuff bring scores down for most. I think 95% of the models on the site would score about half to a full point more in real life.
A Luna
A Lunatic
A 8.0 model to me. The problem is, metallics are heavily and fastly underrated. Its also hard to see any big highlights in metallics too. If you do it really correct, the model will look so incredibly clean and realistic but some people may think it just got a basecoat and there is a big light reflecting all the metal.
This miniature is wooo
tip-top. The artist also tried to add something special to it: the eyes, these were the first things that got me. Awesome miniature, and IMO it has the mark it deserves to have.
This miniature is wooo
tip-top. The artist also tried to add something special to it: the eyes, these were the first things that got me. Awesome miniature, and IMO it has the mark it deserves to have.starchaser1
New member
the rateing is going up as it should
I\'d say its probably underrated, but cmon voting tends to be all over the place. My latest entry is getting lots of 5\'s; I think many don\'t grasp the concept of \"tabletop quality\".
I\'ve got stressed about it before, but I\'m starting to see that the votes aren\'t worth much and not worth being concerned with. I\'m going to continue to show my minis here in hopes of getting input and feedback; it\'s definitely worth it. :beer:
P.S. To be perfectly honest, I could see myself giving that a 7 if I was burning through the gallery. It\'s a great job, but - *yawn*-... another space marine. 40K in general is so played out... (totally my own opinion, don\'t lynch me!! :no: )
I\'ve got stressed about it before, but I\'m starting to see that the votes aren\'t worth much and not worth being concerned with. I\'m going to continue to show my minis here in hopes of getting input and feedback; it\'s definitely worth it. :beer:
P.S. To be perfectly honest, I could see myself giving that a 7 if I was burning through the gallery. It\'s a great job, but - *yawn*-... another space marine. 40K in general is so played out... (totally my own opinion, don\'t lynch me!! :no: )
AinuLainour
New member
It settled into a more deserved score quickly. Declaring a mini underrated after less than 50 votes is a not really necessary though.
alextheartist
New member
Well i made it got the score it deserved, rather the 7.0 it was getting origionally.
Alex
Alex
Amazon warrior
New member
I\'d agree. Another Space Marine...meh... Between 7 and 8 seems about right.
freakinacage
Well-known member
too early to comment on the voting. wait till 100 votes
AinuLainour
New member
How many votes were up when you made the thread?
alextheartist
New member
23 or somthing?? I was going to put a thread up any way cos i though it was cool... honest..
Alex
Alex
The whole voting issue is subjective as has been stated many times before. One person\'s wonderful space marine, is anothers \"Meh SpaM\".
Personally, it doesn\'t \"Rock my world\".
Personally, it doesn\'t \"Rock my world\".
