Units left with d3 wounds and attachments

[titfilou]

The FAQ reads
" LAST STAND
Q: Does this Attack benefit from the Abilities of any Attachments
in the unit?
A: Yes, assuming they were destroyed by same Attack/effect that
triggered the destruction of the unit. "

WHAT IS DEAD MAY NEVER DIE reads
"When a friendly unit is destroyed ::
That unit is not destroyed, but instead remains in play with d3 Wounds."
(selyse and shiren necessary sacrifices goes with the same mechanic)

Here is the situation : a unit containing asha and qarl is attacked
1/1 Hit goes unblocked and Qarl is destroyed.
2/The panic test is failed and Asha (and thus the whole unit is destroyed)
3/The defender plays What is dead may never die and rolls a 3.

The question is "does qarl come back because he was killed during the same attack?" or is it crossing rules that have nothing to do with one another ?

 

[CMON Michael Shinall]

In your specific situation the unit was destroyed as a result of a failed Panic Test, which in turn triggered What is Dead May Never Die. While the Panic Test was part of an Attack Action, the specific step in which the unit was destroyed matters.

In this case Asha, being the last potential model removed, remains, and (should you roll well enough) a further 1-2 standard Infantry models are returned. Qarl was destroyed during a previous event/step (failed Defense Dice in this case). This would be no different if some other effect killed a Character during an Attack (such as Expert Duelist, for example).