Please make it stop!

Madharia

New member
This is my first monster.
I have never painted a skeleton before, so don\'t be too harsh.
This is my first GW figure, so it\'s not the best one ever.

Heard this before? I thought so too.

Possible scenario :
You are a good painter, but you haven\'t painted any other than Games Workshop figures. You think they turn out well and you send them to CoolMiniOrNot. The figures get averages over 8, and you are happy. A few months later, you see your first Rackham figure, and buy it. You paint it well, and send it to CoolMiniOrNot with a description like this: This is my first Rackham figure, so, please, don\'t be too harsh. The figure itself is painted well, and would deserve an average of 9.2, but that\'s not what people think. The average drops to 8.5 because of the description that makes people think you are lying. You are really sad and start spamming the forums.

Just what I am thinking about things.
 

No Such Agency

New member
If it\'s your first mini posted on the site, you might feel legitimately compelled to say \"this is my first mini here\". If it\'s your first Rackham mini after painting loads of GW (for example), it should be just as good as your last GW figure, so asking us to be kind should be wholly unneccessary. Unless you\'re still a terrible painter that is :) In general I find that pleas for leniency don\'t move me much - if you want kindness, ask your mom. We\'re here to try and become better painters (and to show off, of course), and part of that is honestly assessing each other\'s work. I owe much of my last few years\' improvement to the \"unkind\" voting and blunt criticism of CMON.
 

TobiWan

New member
Originally posted by No Such Agency
In general I find that pleas for leniency don\'t move me much - if you want kindness, ask your mom.
Absolutely. And I usually don\'t feel like writing something of this kind: \"I love the way you equally distributed the metallic paint between armour and flesh parts.\"
This wouldn\'t help anyone. :)
It\'s better to something like \"You\'ll have to try and paint a little more cleanly. It\'s not as hard as it seems - a little practice will get you there.\"

Have a nice day,
Tobi
 
Back To Top
Top