I've been spending way too much time with trying to get some skin tones that I like and finally came up with some stuff with the GW paint colors.
I based my color choices on bailey03's (if it's not bailey03's, my sincerest apologies. Someone please let me know which forum member it belongs to) brilliant Skin Tones tutorial seen here:
http://powellminipainting.blogspot.com/p/painting-skin-tones.html
I don't have Reaper paints but this is what I came up with
Chestnut Brown 9071: 50/50 mix of Mournfang Brown and Doombull Brown
Rosy Brown 9067: 50/50 of Bugman's Glow and Cadian Fleshtone
Rosy Skin 9068: Cadian Fleshtone
Fair Skin 9047: Kislev Flesh
Fair Highlights 9048: Pallid Wych Flesh
Pure White 9039: White Scar
Here is what the Bugman's Glow/Cadian Fleshtone mix looks like as a base coat:
View attachment 49405