I just bought one (it was released here last week). Here\'s what I think about it.
1) The fan is frickin loud, although I can\'t hear it when playing Ghost Recon or watching a DVD, it is excessively loud.
2) I bought it as much to stream MP3s and watch DVDs as play games. I\'ve just moved house so can\'t comment on the music yet, but it is hooked up to my 5.1 speakers via a SB extigy and optical cable and works fine. Plays CDs ok as well, but I agree it does seem quieter than my old setup.
3) Ghost recon was a surprise, I usually suck at those games, but I\'m having quite a bit of fun with this, although I am stuck at the moment.
4) The games are too expensive for me. But then I\'m a bargain basement PC gamer, so I expect my games to cost $25 or less, not up to $120.
5) Haven\'t checked out Live yet (due to no internet coz of moving house), but I expect I\'ll be playing more downloaded games than shop bought ones.
6) I like the controller, I\'ve not had any sore finger or thumb issues, but it seems that its not responding very well, especially the cross shaped button. I can\'t seem to reliably get it to accept the direction I\'m trying to push. Be interested to know if this is a common problem or if my unit may be faulty.
So far, I happy enough, if it streams my MP3s ok, then I\'ll definitely stick with it. My last console was a megadrive and I have to say I think I\'m really a PC gamer.
I now have a hankering for a HD TV... curses...