Paint Aid and the fun begins

supervike

Super Moderator
I agree!!

Originally posted by paintingploddy
$3550.00 - I\'m feeling good at this point. I also note that the money raised is pledged to go to the American red Cross. I think at the end of the day, though the intent was to support the Tsunami Victims the Red Cross (at least in Australia) discloses the money may be used for other purposes, including helping those hurt by Katrina. Please tell me if I\'m wrong.???

I was a bit disturbed when I saw that note too. This money was earmarked for Tsunami Relief and it should go there. Those people still need help, badly.
 

Starfall

New member
I bet the final price will be $3,550.00.
Excactly 3 minutes now!

Edit: Yes, 3550 Dollars. And the winner is... frotherbloodfinger! Cheers!

Plus Games Workshop\'s 3550 that\'s a nice bunch of money, $7100...
 

Klute

New member
100% of the final sale price will support American Red Cross

Giving Works Item
Charities Mission Statement
The American Red Cross is a national network of nearly 900 field units, 1-million volunteers and 36,000 employees dedicated to saving lives and helping people prevent, prepare for and respond to emergencies. All items sold to benefit the Red Cross after August 29th, 2005 will support the American Red Cross Disaster Relief Fund, which will enable the Red Cross to provide shelter, food, counseling and other assistance to victims of Hurricane Katrina and other disasters.


SOMEBODY TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE
:mad:
 

supervike

Super Moderator
I don\'t know what that means Klute. I posted about it on last page too. I hope it can be explained.

It seems to be just the Red Cross\' Mission statement, BUT that money should be going to Tsunami relief..
 

Beelzebrush

Active member
Originally posted by Klute
100% of the final sale price will support American Red Cross

Giving Works Item
Charities Mission Statement
The American Red Cross is a national network of nearly 900 field units, 1-million volunteers and 36,000 employees dedicated to saving lives and helping people prevent, prepare for and respond to emergencies. All items sold to benefit the Red Cross after August 29th, 2005 will support the American Red Cross Disaster Relief Fund, which will enable the Red Cross to provide shelter, food, counseling and other assistance to victims of Hurricane Katrina and other disasters.


SOMEBODY TELL ME THIS IS NOT TRUE
:mad:

Hmmm.... would appear to be the case. If so, what a humungous f**k-up. Also, are GW going to double this final fee if this is the destination of the funds? I really really hope this isn\'t the case.
 

Klute

New member
Originally posted by supervike
I don\'t know what that means Klute. I posted about it on last page too. I hope it can be explained.

It seems to be just the Red Cross\' Mission statement, BUT that money should be going to Tsunami relief..


IMHO
This issue needs sorting out.
 

Baltius

New member
I understand the original purpose of the army was to aid the victims of the Tsunami but I don\'t see what the problem would be as long as it goes to people who really need the help. That is what the spirit of the whole idea was and is.
 

MarkusTay

New member
I noticed that the first day of the Auction...

I was a little upset about it, but decided not to ruffle any feathers. I felt it would just stir up the few nay-sayers and curmudgeons with endless I-told-you-so\'s. What was actually stated was that any funds going to the American Red Cross could not be directed to any one relief effort, and would be spread around amongst all their good works.

The Red Cross is involved in OVER 1500 seperate projects worldwide, so I figure the Tsunami victims will get about $2.00.

I wonder how many of them that will feed? :mad:
 

TAB Studio

New member
Hi all
Let me tell you there is a load I could say on this subject (as well as many other subjects in this project) now that it has ended. My silence here has been an ocean of energy that started within a week of the projects conception.

Now lets go back in time...
http://www.coolminiornot.com/forums/viewthread.php?tid=6980&page=3

And I will place a quote here:
French kid posted this on the page you are linked to \"On the topic of the NGOs that are helping out in asia I have a few links handy somwhere since I\'m organising somthing in my highschool, I\'ll post them as soon as I have time. If you want to send exclusively to the victims of the asia disaster I\'d sugest avoiding the red cross has their donation contract dosn\'t require them to give the money to the cause you have decided to suport should they feel that it would be better spent elswere. MSF isn\'t accepting anymore donation because they feel they have anouth already and unlike the red cross can\'t spend it on somthing els. So that leavs about 3-4 NGOs.\"
People at the time were worried about other things but keep reading..there\'s more.
I checked FK was indeed right

I checked and checked and I found one you could indeed earmark for the one disaster here is the post:
http://www.coolminiornot.com/forums/viewthread.php?tid=6980&page=4

Then pages later I find
\"that the best way to deal with this is act like it is a commission for a client(client being Red Cross),\" it is on this page
\"http://www.coolminiornot.com/forums/post.php?action=reply&fid=4&tid=9976

After that no mention of the matter in any post.

No, on 1/11 /2005 a press release was made and the charity was started as Brothers Brother (which was chosen because it would earmark funds for this specific disaster and got such good reviews by Forbes).....no one complained or apparently really read the thing ..i guess
though people translated it in what 4 languages... and if you read the translations you will see at that time it was brothers keeper

1/18/05 I received a letter from one of the organizers that has since left us stating they would pull out unless it was the Red Cross. It was at the time a very important person you all felt so I was quiet. I responded to many things that had happened to me a few hours later but this refers to the charity.

This quotes my letter 1/18/05 in response:
\"I put the information out there on the forum in the first thread. It was mentioned in the thread that the Red Cross would not ear mark funds for the disaster by another member of this project. Thus I looked for other options. The Forbes report was impressive to me so I posted the information. No one objected nor have they until now. It was posted on EO no neg response. People are concerned with whether their money is used wisely and this organization purchases medical equipment and pharmaceuticals not things to inspire Christianity.\"
In that letter I resigned from all help but the website and I remained that way until the project moved to DR\'s.

As far as the tax receipt the buyer gets that so they may file for the tax credit of their donation.
And as far as GW I feel sure they as well understand the Red Cross and the handling of the money heck the lawyers had to approve linking to the Paint Aid web site let alone where the money was going.
 

green stuff

Active member
What Tracy said is unfortunately true word for word. Paint Aid has been extremely tiring for most of the people organising it. That is why the second edition will be smaller in size and run by one person.

I would like to thank everybody who participated (be it in painting, sculpting, the sponsors, betting, or making the final donation) and most of all a special big thanks to Mike and Tracy for going beyound what was necessary.

For a first edition, I think the result is a success. Just need to streamline some things ;).
 
Time to put the money where the mouth has been.....

Tracy,

Auction is over. Personally, I am a bit disappointed in several ways. I was in Virginia all weekend with no internet access, so I was out of the game ( I knew $3,000 would not hold up ). Second, I really figured $5,000+ on the sale.

The funny thing is that if I had won, I had decided to ask you to re-auction it for Katrina. I have some other ideas as to how to help there. Look for me on those threads in a bit.

Anywho.....I had committed to a donation of 10% of the sale price if I did not win the Ogre Army. Let\'s make it an even $400. I am pleased and proud to help.

For the record, I think all this money needs to go to the Tsunami Relief. I am quite sure it will dry up ( no pun intended ) since so much will now be diverted to the American Southeast.

Let me say again what a wonderful job I think the whole team has done. Congrats to the winner. Thanks for all the well wishes when I was deep in the bidding.

Tracy - Send me an email at cwheeler58@optonline.net to give me instruction on the best way to get my donation to you.
 

paintingploddy

New member
I seem to have opened a can of worms.:(

My view has always been that this is like using electricity, you might want to accept only electricity generated in an environmentally friendly matter, but at the end of the day it comes from great big pool of electricity generated by everything from wind to nuclear. you can\'t choose.

I guess (if it helps) that you are contributing to a pool of funds, mixed together that gives a pool of money able to be directed to several points. By donating this amount you up the pool, and reduce the risk of SE Asia being disadvantaged by the need to allocate funds at home (ie Katrina).

I\'ve probably expressed this poorly, but I believe that at a certain point we surrender control of what we do to others, and that point is near now.

On a related point. TAB, do we know the amount you are going to have to come up with yet for Paypal fees, should the buyer select that method of payment?

Cheers
PP
 

leopardpixie

Active member
A donation is a donation

With all good thought intended, Red Cross will use the money as they see fit. If it be Tsunami victims or another cause, they will put the money where THEY deem fit.
 
Back To Top
Top